Guess who graduated this week?!
No, not me…
She successfully finished Obedience Level 2 at a local dog training facility.
That’s basically the elementary school of dog training — “So it’s not a big deal,” you might conclude.
But you would be wrong.
For Millie, this is basically her PhD in Dog.
This actually stems from fear and lack of confidence, not aggression, but it has been a long journey to get to the point where we can happily finish a group obedience class together (sure, she had maybe 3-4 minor meltdowns per class, but she’d pull herself together again after 10 seconds or so each time — and it was only ever if one of the other dogs started it, so I don’t think she was that bad).
So Millie and I are pretty pleased with ourselves!
Millie’s training saga got me thinking a lot about what dog and human learning has in common. For example, with both dogs and humans, we often approach learning all wrong:
- We expect dogs to learn things on our terms, not theirs, and consider using dog-friendly motivators like treats as ‘bribery’ — while we also fail to connect what we’re trying to learn with our own personal goals and dreams.
- We frighten dogs into avoiding the wrong behaviour (e.g. jumping up) as opposed to teaching dogs to choose the right behaviour (e.g. sit nicely) — while we are also terrified of failure, experimentation and learning from mistakes in our own education.
- We get frustrated and angry when our dogs don’t perform as expected — and we get frustrated and angry at the teacher, course, or other circumstances when things don’t go as planned.
With my own dog, Millie, I’m committed to using scientifically-sound and humane training methods — namely positive reinforcement only, lots of regular treats, praise and happy voices, no punishment or fear required. It’s worked out pretty well for us so far.
But this blog isn’t about dog-training — it’s about how people learn! Here are a few tips I’ve picked up for my own studies after working with Millie for the past 4 months.
Milk what motivates me
Homework can be a real bummer. It’s demoralizing when I can’t figure it out, it often takes way more time than I thought it would, and there are always other, way more fun things I might be doing instead. When I’m teaching Millie a new behaviour, I have to consider what’s most motivating to her. (In this order: 1. Small furry moving prey. 2. The smelliest, meatiest treats. 3. Praise from me (a distant, distant 3rd…).
So what motivates me? What do I love? Delicious food. Going out with friends. What do I want to do when I graduate? A fun, challenging job. My choice of where to live. Working for a cause I believe in.
With this in mind, I’m careful never to work for too long without deciding on a fun reward, something to look forward to, at the end. I also keep my eye on the big picture when I’m feeling drained. Countdowns help — university terms are quite short (12-14 weeks), as is the degree itself in the long run. I like to purposefully choose these rewards and schedule them proactively so that I can see them coming up in the calendar.
Millie isn’t a machine; she needs to know what’s in it for her when it comes to training. Same goes for me and math homework.
Treat practice problems like play
Currently I’m blasting through Khan Academy’s Integral Calculus section. As a recovering perfectionist, I take it pretty personally when I’m on my nth practice problem and still getting most of them wrong. I have to keep reminding myself that these practice problems aren’t final exams, nobody is judging me, and it’s only by getting these wrong, staying lighthearted about it, and learning from the experience that I’ll actually learn the concepts.
Traditional dog training keeps the dog so scared of making a mistake, they’re afraid to do anything at all. These dogs seem well-behaved on the surface since they’re so calm and docile, but in fact they’re often pretty stressed. Dogs trained with positive methods burst with enthusiasm and good behaviours — you can tell they are having a blast as they zoom around the agility ring, for example. The way to get dogs like this? Reward good behaviours and treat every training session like a game!
I focus so much on my mistakes that I fail to notice my success, which means I often feel stressed and tired about my homework before I even start. That doesn’t feel good, and it also means I’m more likely to procrastinate doing the work. I’m trying to flip this dynamic — focus on what’s good, what am I doing right, and use that information to do better next time at the hard problems. My hope is that one day I’ll treat homework as a fun experiment without any fear of messing up.
Avoid the blame game
I hear a lot of dog owners say things like, “Well, my dog is just so stupid he could never…” or “My dog is so stubborn she could never …” I also hear students (and myself!) blaming the course, the teacher, the circumstances, etc. when things go wrong — a failed test, misunderstood homework assignment, bad grade.
What’s the use in that?
This isn’t to say that courses, teachers, and circumstances are never to blame for bad outcomes. Of course they are — sometimes. But most of the time, those elements are out of our control — in the same way that our dogs’ temperaments, histories and genetics are out of our control, too. I think those feelings of bitterness and blame only bring ourselves down without improving the situation at all. It might bring a short-term relief because the outcome is no longer my fault, but now I have to carry those negative feelings around with me. Gross!
Better, I think, to take responsibility for the parts that are in our control — “My reinforcement timing was off with the dog at that point,” “I didn’t think to check in with the teaching assistant before handing in the assignment” — and then just let go of the rest. Move on. Know better for next time.
All easier said than done, I know. Don’t blame me! 😉